☰

Overview: Rethinking collaborative water governance in South Africa

Estimated Time
15 minutes
Resource Type
Blog
Language
English
Published
2025

This blog provides a summary of an experiment funded by a TIPC member, the Department for Science, Technology and Innovation in South Africa. It describes how the Living Catchments Project was used to test Transformative Innovation Policy (TIP) approaches to water governance. For original material from the collaboration, browse all Living Catchments project resources.

Water insecurity is one of South Africa’s most urgent socio-ecological challenges and a growing threat to livelihoods, development and climate resilience.

The South African National Biodiversity Institute (SANBI), together with the Water Research Commission (WRC) and the Department of Science and Innovation (DSI), plays a central role in addressing these challenges — yet, as in many countries, water management has historically been structured around technical and infrastructure-led solutions.

In response to the Water Research, Development and Innovation Roadmap, an experimental engagement with the Transformative Innovation Policy Consortium (TIPC) set out to explore how a transformative approach could reframe collaboration, ecological integration and decision-making within catchment areas.

Key challenges

Despite advanced technical expertise, South Africa’s water system faces systemic challenges that hinder integrated, sustainable governance. These include:

  • Compromised ecological infrastructure: Wetlands, mountain catchments and rivers — critical for natural water regulation — may be degraded and under-protected.
  • Ageing built infrastructure: Supply systems may be unable to keep up with demand and require ongoing maintenance and investment from diverse actors.
  • Fragmented governance: Responsibilities for water, biodiversity, land-use and development planning are distributed across multiple institutions. Catchment management demands long-term collaboration and new capacities for facilitation and relational work.
  • Weak integration of ecological infrastructure in policy practice: Ecological infrastructure is not consistently factored into national or regional water planning despite its strategic importance.

The Living Catchments Project was created to address some of these issues. Implemented by SANBI, it is one of the flagship projects of the Water Research, Development and Innovation Roadmap programme. It is a pioneering initiative aimed at strengthening communities of practice, linking ecological and built infrastructure and building new capabilities for collaborative, inclusive water governance.

The project is rooted in the recognition that water security is a socio-technical system challenge and that addressing it depends on collaboration between the landscape that delivers the water, the infrastructure that delivers that water to people and the communities that rely on the water, including industry and agriculture.

It was jointly selected by SANBI, WRC, the DSI and TIPC as an important initiative already generating meaningful learning. Applying Transformative Innovation Policy tools and frameworks offered a way to stretch its transformative potential — helping partners deepen their understanding of water governance through a systemic lens.

Activities

Over 16 weeks in 2020 — and through multiple activities before and after — SANBI, WRC, DSI and TIPC researchers undertook a collaborative, iterative experiment to apply TIP principles to stretch the transformative potential of the Living Catchments Project.

At the core of the project was the establishment and strengthening of Communities of Practice in four Strategic Water Source Area (SWSA) catchments: uMzimvubu, uThukela, Berg–Breede and the Olifants. These brought together local communities, catchment conveners, technical specialists, public officials, researchers and social learning practitioners. They served as safe, neutral spaces for dialogue, mutual learning and coordinated action.

The experiment was originally conceived as a face-to-face collaboration, but due to the Covid-19 pandemic all of the co-creation sessions took place online. Seven intensive online sessions took place involving practitioners and researchers, organised over three modules, including:

  1. Reflecting on theories of change
    • Developing a shared understanding of the project’s purpose and mapping early ideas of how change might happen.
    • Stress-testing the theory of change through transitions frameworks and system analysis.
  2. Stretching the project theory of change using Transformative Outcomes
    • Exploring transformative outcomes and their relevance to the project.
    • Considering ‘shielding’ as a transformative outcome — creating protected spaces for learning and experimentation.
    • Mapping pathways of change and revisiting the theory of change to identify further learning opportunities.
  3. Developing a monitoring, evaluation and learning (MEL) plan
    • Designing a MEL framework and indicators based on insights from the experiment.
    • Refining key questions and shaping a practical learning agenda.

Throughout the process, participants analysed the role of ecological infrastructure, the need for integration between policy, science and implementation, and issues of power, participation and knowledge flows. The group worked with several TIP concepts and tools, including:

  • Transformative Theory of Change, to map systemic barriers, change pathways and long-term visions.
  • Transformative Outcomes, such as building niches, supporting reflexive learning and expanding networks.
  • Formative Evaluation, supporting adaptive monitoring, evaluation and learning rather than compliance-focused reporting.

The collaboration led to several outputs, including a revised graphic theory of change, an updated MEL framework, actor and relationship maps, a cross-catchment outcomes pathway and reflections from participants on the co-creation process.

Living Catchments Theory of Change

Based on testimonies in interviews and learning events, practitioners reported that the process led to:

  • Embedding ecological-infrastructure thinking into national water and biodiversity planning, reframing rivers, wetlands and ecosystems as equally important to built infrastructure.
  • Broader stakeholder inclusion and shared ownership, expanding participation across government, civil society and environmental actors.
  • Collective skills development for transformative change, including stronger reflexivity and shared language for systemic transformation.
  • Improved organisational monitoring, evaluation and learning capacities, enabling projects to adapt and challenge assumptions during implementation.

Learnings and next steps

The experiment revealed that transformative water governance requires more than technical innovation. It also depends on relationships, reflexivity, institutional change and new conditions for collaboration.

Participants observed that transformation requires dialogue and mutual recognition across knowledge systems and the creation of ‘shielded spaces’ for experimentation and learning.

Future activities will focus on strengthening integrated water governance through:

  • Resourcing social spaces that connect ecological and built infrastructure.
  • Developing learning opportunities across catchment areas.
  • Institutionalising communities of practice for long-term collaboration.
  • Recognising social learning and relationships as essential change capital.
  • Improving policy guidance and ensuring it is integrated into decision-making.

Contributions to the SDGs

Learnings from the experiment contribute to several Sustainable Development Goals:

  • SDG 6 – Clean Water and Sanitation
  • SDG 11 – Sustainable Cities and Communities
  • SDG 13 – Climate Action
  • SDG 15 – Life on Land
  • SDG 17 – Partnerships for the Goals

References and further reading

 

Citation

Transformative Innovation Policy Consortium (2025) Overview: Rethinking collaborative water governance in South Africa. TIP Resource Lab. Available at: https://tipresourcelab.net/resource/overview-rethinking-collaborative-water-governance-in-south-africa/

Leave your feedback on the resource

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *